Ryan O’Neal Wins Appeals Ruling In Defamation Case
Ryan O’Neal speaks to Billy Bush and Kit Hoover via satellite from New York City for Access Hollywood Live, May 2012
LOS ANGELES, Calif. --
Ryan O’Neal may have enough evidence to show that he was defamed by a man who claimed the actor stole a valuable portrait of the late Farrah Fawcett, an appeals court ruled Thursday.
A divided panel of the 2nd District Court of Appeal ruled that O’Neal’s case against Craig Nevius, a former Fawcett associate, should be allowed to proceed and that the actor may be able to win some damages. One justice disagreed and wrote that the case should be dismissed.
O’Neal sued in July 2011, claiming he was defamed by Nevius’ comments that the actor had stolen a Fawcett portrait created by Andy Warhol. The painting is the subject of a separate lawsuit between O’Neal and the University of Texas, which claims Fawcett left the artwork to the school after her 2009 death.
Nevius’s attorney, Lincoln Bandlow, said he would appeal the ruling to the California Supreme Court. He had appealed a lower court’s ruling allowing the case to go forward.
O’Neal’s suit seeks more than $1 million in damages. He claimed in the case that Warhol gave him the portrait and he intends to bequeath it to his only son from his longtime relationship with Fawcett, Redmond O’Neal.
Nevius’ comments that O’Neal stole the artwork were made in interviews with Star magazine and “Good Morning America,” and he cooperated with UT investigators searching for the portrait.
Although Nevius initially denied he accused O’Neal of stealing the painting, he acknowledged in a later court filing that he made the claim to university investigators.
“The inferences reasonably drawn from the evidence here would support a jury’s finding that Nevius harbored strong ill-feelings toward O’Neal,” the justices siding with O’Neal wrote. The dissent argues that Nevius’ comments were constitutionally-protected speech and the case should have been dismissed.
O’Neal’s fight with UT over the portrait returns to court on Feb. 27.
The actor and Nevius have battled in court for years.
Nevius collaborated on a documentary of Fawcett’s fight with cancer but sued the actor claiming he interfered in the project and removed him from it shortly before Fawcett’s death. The case was dismissed before trial.
Copyright 2013 by Associated Press. All rights reserved.
This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Celebs Who Have Been In Rehab
Find out which celebs have spent some time in rehab and what landed them there.
Hollywood Legends: Present & Past
Elizabeth Taylor, Lauren Bacall, Kirk Douglas, Clint Eastwood and more!
Former ‘Charlie’s Angel’ Jaclyn Smith
Check out these photos of the lovely Jacyln Smith over the years!
In Memoriam: The Stars We Lost During Summer 2009
From Michael Jackson to DJ AM — the stars we lost in summer 2009 remembered.
Access’ Top 10 Emmy Snubs & Surprises 2009
The Emmy nominations are in! Check out some shocking nominees and who got snubbed!
Hollywood’s Best Hairdos
Find out which locks have stood the test of time!
Farrah Fawcett & Ryan O’Neal: A Love Story
Check out these shots of Farrah and Ryan from over the years…
Farrah Fawcett TV & Filmography
Check out some of Farrah’s many roles over the years
Farrah Fawcett: From ‘Angel’ To Icon
Check out recent photos of the lovely Farrah Fawcett
Farrah Fawcett, The Early Years: The Making Of An ‘Angel’
Check out early pictures from the life & career of the lovely Farrah Fawcett…
Ryan O’Neal Wins Appeals Ruling In Defamation Case
Ryan O’Neal On Postponing Cancer Battle & How Farrah Fawcett Changed His Thoughts On Death
Ryan O’Neal Says He Has Stage 2 Prostate Cancer; Doctors Expect Him To Make A Full Recovery
Ryan O’Neal Battling Stage Four Prostate Cancer; Expects ‘Full Recovery’
Judge Praises Farrah Fawcett Son Redmond O’Neal For Progress In Drug Treatment Program
Redmond O’Neal Headed Back To Jail; Could Be Sent Away For Up To 6 Years
Ryan O’Neal: ‘I Will Win’ ‘Dancing With The Stars’ Next Season; Talks Strained Tatum Relationship
Redmond O’Neal Sentenced To One Year Of In-Patient Rehab Over Recent Arrest
Son Of Farrah Fawcett, Ryan O’Neal Pleads Not Guilty To Felony Heroin, Gun Possession In LA
Prosecutors Charge Son Of Farrah Fawcett, Ryan O’Neal With Felony Heroin Possession In LA
Ryan O’Neal Sues Ex-Fawcett Associate For Defamation For Comments About Disputed Warhol Art
Tatum O’Neal’s ' ‘Work In Progress’ Relationship With Dad Ryan O’Neal
Ryan O’Neal Helping Son Redmond Through Grief On ‘The O’Neals’
Ryan O’Neal To Write About Farrah Fawcett In Memoir Scheduled To Be Published Next Year
Meet Your New ‘Charlie’s Angels’!: Rachael Taylor, Minka Kelly & Annie Ilonzeh Shoot Pilot In Miami
‘Charlie’s Angels’ Reboot Finds Its Bosley
Farrah Fawcett’s Red Swimsuit Going To Smithsonian
Minka Kelly & Rachael Taylor Reportedly In Talks For ABC’s ‘Charlie’s Angels’ Reboot
Katie Holmes In Talks To Return To Broadway For Psychological Drama
Redmond O’Neal Completes Drug Diversion Program
Former ‘Charlie’s Angels’ Star Kate Jackson Writing Memoir, Scheduled For June 2011
O’Neal Family On Remembering Farrah Fawcett: ‘It Hurts’
Friends, Family Honor Farrah Fawcett On Anniversary
Tori Spelling Reveals Psychic Encounter With Farrah Fawcett
Producer & Former Friend Of Farrah Fawcett Claims Actress’ Estate Money Being Misused
Alana Stewart’s Dark Times: What Happened?
Alana Stewart was married to George Hamilton and then to Rod Stewart and was close friends with Farrah Fawcett. But early on, life took a dark turn for Alana as she details in her candid autobiography, “Rearview Mirror.”
Ryan O’Neal Reflects On His Love For Farrah Fawcett & The Death Of Michael Jackson
Ryan O’Neal looks back on his love affair with Farrah Fawcett, but why didn’t they ever marry? Plus, did he think that the fact that Michael Jackson died the same day as Farrah Fawcett, overshadowed Farrah’s death? Also, what did he think of Jackson dating his daughter Tatum O’Neal? Ryan’s book, “Both of Us: My Life with Farrah,” is in stores now.
Ryan O’Neal: Does He Think That He Was A Bad Parent?
Three out of four of Ryan O’Neal’s kids have had addiction issues, so does Ryan think that he has done a poor job raising his kids? How is his relationship with his kids at the moment, specifically daughter Tatum O’Neal? Ryan’s book, “Both of Us: My Life with Farrah,” is in stores now.
Ryan O’Neal: Has He Given Up The Will To Live Due To Cancer Battles?
Ryan O’Neal reveals that he is battling three types of cancer at the moment, so has he given up the will to live? Plus, why hasn’t he started treatment for his stage II prostate cancer yet? Also, does he view death differently following Farrah Fawcett’s death? Ryan’s book, “Both of Us: My Life with Farrah,” is in stores now.
Has Ryan O’Neal Given Up On Life?
In a candid new interview, Ryan O’Neal opens up about his battle with three different cancers in his body — but is Farrah Fawcett’s longtime love ready to give up the fight?
Ryan O’Neal’s Update On Redmond O’Neal: Is He Worried About His Son? (September 13, 2011)
Ryan O’Neal chats with Access at the Farrah Fawcett Foundation event hosted by Give Back Hollywood about how his son, Redmond, is doing. Where is he now? Plus, why does Redmond scare Ryan?
Ryan O’Neal Slams Oprah Over His OWN Reality Show ‘Ryan & Tatum: The O’Neals’
Ryan O’Neal chats with Access at the Farrah Fawcett Foundation event hosted by Give Back Hollywood about his reality show, “The O’Neals.” Did the reality program do anything to help improve his strained relationship with his daughter, Tatum? Plus, why is Ryan O’Neal unhappy with the way Oprah handled the series?
Ryan O’Neal Discusses How Farrah Fawcett Came Between Him & His Daughter, Tatum O’Neal
Ryan O’Neal chats with Access guest correspondent Jayde Donovan about when he first met Farrah Fawcett and how she subsequently came between him and his daughter, Tatum. Is there anything he would do differently now? Plus, what was it like for him and his son, Redmond, when they visited Farrah’s grave together?
Jaclyn Smith On Farrah Fawcett’s Death: I ‘Can’t Believe A Year’s Gone By’
Farrah’s pal and “Charlie’s Angels” co-star Jaclyn Smith discusses paying tribute to the fallen star at the one-year anniversary of her passing and spending time with Farrah’s troubled son, Redmond. Plus, how is Jaclyn giving back to cancer survivors?
Access Extended: Jaclyn Smith On Farrah Fawcett’s Death - I ‘Can’t Believe A Year’s Gone By’
Jaclyn Smith reflects with Access’ Tony Potts about the one-year anniversary of Farrah Fawcett’s death, but has time healed all?
Lenny Clarke & Tatum O’Neal Talk ‘Rescue Me’ At Season 6 Premiere, New York
Lenny Clarke talks with Access about how he lost 177 pounds. Then, he discusses his character losing his wife and shooting Tommy. Plus, Tatum O’Neal talks about wrapping up the final season. Also, will she be attending Farrah Fawcett’s memorial in LA?
Tori Spelling’s Psychic Moment: Did She Really Speak With Farrah Fawcett?
Tori Spelling talks with Access about visiting a psychic with the hopes of being able to talk to her late father, Aaron Spelling. So, what happened when the late Farrah Fawcett allegedly started talking to her? Plus, did she pass along any messages to Farrah’s family?
2010 TV Land Awards Red Carpet: Ryan O’Neal & Tatum O’Neal Remember Farrah
Ryan O’Neal hits the 8th Annual TV Land Awards where he tells Access how he is set to introduce the Farrah Fawcett tribute that will be shown. Plus, Tatum O’Neal comments about Ryan and Farrah’s relationship and how honoring Farrah’s legacy has meant so much to Ryan.
Ryan & Tatum O’Neal Reunite After Years Of Estrangement
Thanks to Farrah Fawcett — father and daughter Ryan & Tatum are back together after being estranged for years because of a very public war-of-words about Tatum’s childhood.
Alana Stewart Celebrates ‘My Journey With Farrah’ Book
Alana Stewart talks about how she is missing her friend and wishes that she could be with her at this party. She also talks about how she hopes this book will help people understand that their loved ones are the most important thing in the world.
Alana Stewart: ‘I Haven’t Fully Processed’ Farrah’s Death (August 11, 2009)
Alana Stewart talks with Access Hollywood about the days leading up to Farrah Fawcett’s death. What were Farrah’s feelings towards her son Redmond and his father, Ryan O’Neal? And, why is Alana calling the press despicable?
Farrah Fawcett’s Funeral (June 30, 2009)
Friends and family, including Ryan O’Neal, son Redmond and good friend Alana Stewart, come together to say farewell to Farrah Fawcett at the Cathedral of Our Lady of the Angels in LA.
Fans Send Messages To Michael Jackson and Farrah Fawcett
Access Hollywood viewers send in letters of support and thoughts to the friends and families of Michael and Farrah during this difficult time.
‘Farrah’s Story’ Premieres In LA (May 13, 2009)
Friends and family come together at the Paley Center in LA to watch Farrah Fawcett’s documentary, “Farrah’s Story.” Ryan O’Neal, Alana Stewart and Dr. Ursula Jacob talk with Nancy O’Dell about Farrah’s condition. “Farrah’s Story” premieres May 15 on NBC.
Meet The Man Behind Farrah Fawcett’s Iconic Poster
Farrah Fawcett’s iconic poster has sold over 12 million copies, and in a rare interview Access introduces you to the man behind the jaw-dropping image.
Access Archives: Farrah Fawcett On The Record (1997)
Back in 1997, Access sat down with a then-50-year-old Farrah Fawcett to talk about fame, the biggest misconceptions people have about her & dealing with the aftermath of her much-talked about interview with David Letterman.
Access Exclusive: Farrah Fawcett Gives Health Update
The legendary Farrah Fawcett leaves a game of paddle tennis at a friends’ house and looks energized and healthy. Farrah is asked if she would like to say anything to all the fans who are praying for her and she says, “I won, for today.”
Access Extended: Tatum O’Neal
Tatum talks with Maria Menounos about her acting career, raising her kids, young Hollywood misbehaving and Farrah Fawcett’s struggle with cancer and how that has affected her family.