MovieMantz Review: ‘Disney’s A Christmas Carol’
FIRST PUBLISHED: November 5, 2009 3:50 PM EST
LAST UPDATED: November 5, 2009 4:51 PM EST
LOS ANGELES, Calif. --
“The Taming of the Scrooge”
“Disney’s A Christmas Carol”
Jim Carrey, Robin Wright Penn, Gary Oldman
Directed by Robert Zemeckis
‘Tis the season to be jolly, right? Well, not to sound like a Scrooge or anything, but does the world really need another version of “A Christmas Carol?”
Check out the Internet Movie Database, which lists more than 50 versions done for both TV and film over the last hundred years. The Charles Dickens classic has been told so many times since it was first published in 1843 that it’s become embedded into our subconscious. So even if you never read the book, the odds are that you still know the story (and if you don’t, shame on you).
And it seems like everyone’s taken a shot at playing the ultimate party-pooper, from Yosemite Sam to Mister Magoo, from George C. Scott to Bill Murray. Now it’s Jim Carrey’s turn, which would have been noteworthy enough if it wasn’t for the fact that he’s also playing several other roles: the ghosts of Christmas Past, Present and Yet to Come.
It’s all thanks to Oscar-winning director Robert Zemeckis (“Forrest Gump”), who once again utilizes the complex motion-capture technique that he first pioneered with 2004’s “The Polar Express.” But while the special effects in that film and its follow-up, 2007’s “Beowulf,” were visually stunning, the characters were often criticized for looking too lifeless to resonate on an emotional level.
Zemeckis appears to have solved that problem – especially in the eyes, which finally seem to sparkle with life – but the story (adapted by Zemeckis) sticks so close to the source material that it’s familiar to a fault. So despite all the bells, whistles and other 3-D gimmicks used to take moviegoers on a wild ride above 19th century London, in the end, it’s still the same old story.
And one has to wonder why Zemeckis bothered creating computer-generated characters that look just like the actors playing them. After all, nothing beats the real thing, especially where Jim Carrey’s rubberfaced antics are concerned. As for Colin Firth (who plays Scrooge’s nephew Fred), Gary Oldman (Bob Cratchit) and Robin Wright Penn (Scrooge’s lost love Belle), their performances would have had a stronger impact if they weren’t covered by special effects.
But even from a structural point of view, “Disney’s A Christmas Carol” is uneven and far too long. It starts off slow and intense, and it’s actually a lot scarier than some of the other kid-friendly versions (it is, after all, a ghost story). But it’s still visually exciting, especially after Scrooge’s encounter with the first ghost.
Zemeckis hasn’t directed a traditional live-action movie since “Cast Away” in 2000, and judging by his next project, the computer-generated remake of “Yellow Submarine” (which will bring him full-circle with The Beatles after directing 1978’s “I Wanna Hold Your Hand”), he’s not going to anytime soon. As for his version of the Dickens classic, it’s visually stunning and all, but this is one version of “A Christmas Carol” that the world can probably live without. Humbug!
Verdict: SKIP IT!
Copyright 2009 by NBC Universal, Inc. All rights reserved.
This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Keep your Access to everything in Hollywood! Breaking news and personal commentary from Nancy, Billy, Tony, Shaun, Maria & all of our producers! Follow us on Facebook and Twitter now!
MovieMantz Reviews: Michael Jackson’s ‘This Is It’
Access’ Scott “Movie” Mantz takes on Michael Jackson’s highly anticipated “This Is It” film. Was this movie fit for a King?
MovieMantz: Top 10 Baseball Movies Of All-Time
More Articles
-
MovieMantz Review: ‘Disney’s A Christmas Carol’
-
MovieMantz: Top 10 Baseball Movies Of All-Time
-
MovieMantz Review: ‘This Is It’
-
MovieMantz Review: ‘An Education’
-
MovieMantz Review: ‘Where the Wild Things Are’
-
MovieMantz Review: ‘Paranormal Activity’
-
See It/Skip It: ‘Invention Of Lying,’ ‘Zombieland’ & More!
-
MovieMantz Review: ‘Capitalism: A Love Story’
-
MovieMantz Review: ‘Up In The Air’
-
MovieMantz Review: ‘Surrogates’
-
See It/Skip It: ‘Jennifer’s Body,’ ‘Love Happens,’ ‘The Informant!’ & More
-
MovieMantz Review: ‘All About Steve’
-
MovieMantz Review: ‘The September Issue’
-
MovieMantz Review: ‘Inglourious Basterds’
-
See It/Skip It: ‘District 9,’ ‘The Time Traveler’s Wife’ & ‘Ponyo’
-
MovieMantz Review: ‘District 9’
-
MovieMantz Review: ‘Funny People’
-
SEE IT/SKIP IT: ‘The Ugly Truth,’ ‘Orphan’ & ‘G-Force’
-
MovieMantz Review: '(500) Days of Summer’
-
MovieMantz Review: ‘Bruno’
-
MovieMantz Review: ‘Public Enemies’
-
MovieMantz Review: ‘Transformers: Revenge Of The Fallen’
-
MovieMantz Review: ‘The Proposal’
-
MovieMantz Review: ‘The Taking Of Pelham 1 2 3’
-
MovieMantz Review: ‘Land of the Lost’
More Videos
-
MovieMantz Reviews: Michael Jackson’s ‘This Is It’
Access’ Scott “Movie” Mantz takes on Michael Jackson’s highly anticipated “This Is It” film. Was this movie fit for a King?
-
MovieMantz Reviews: ‘Amelia’, ‘Astro Boy’ & More (October 23, 2009)
Access’ Scott “Movie” Mantz takes on a whole slew of films opening this weekend from “Amelia” to “An Education” to “Astro Boy” and more, but which ones get his seal of approval?
-
Box Office Showdown: A ‘Wild’ Weekend At The Box Office (October 19, 2009)
“Where The Wild Things Are” ruled the box office, coming in #1 with over $32 million. Meanwhile, Jamie Foxx and Gerard Butler’s “Law Abiding Citizen” came in second with over $21 million and “Paranormal Activity” was third with over $19 million.
-
MovieMantz Review: ‘Paranormal Activity’ & ‘Where The Wild Things Are’ (10/17/09)
Scott “Movie” Mantz says that “Paranormal Activity” is one of the best scary movies that he has seen in a long time - so will you be able to sleep after seeing it? Meanwhile, Scott found “Where The Wild Things Are” to be a bit depressing, but should you still see it?
-
Oren Peli’s ‘Paranormal Activity’ Is A Fright Fest
Director Oren Peli talks with Access about his movie, “Paranormal Activity,” and how “The Blair Witch Project” inspired him. Plus, what suggestions did Steven Spielberg give Oren about the ending of the film?
-
MovieMantz Reviews: ‘Paranormal Activity’ & ‘Couples Retreat’
Scott “Movie” Mantz is calling “Paranormal Activity” the scariest movie he’s seen in a long time. But, he thinks that Vince Vaughn’s comedy, “Couples Retreat,” is scary for a whole other reason.
-
Box Office Showdown: ‘Zombieland’ Kills The Competition (October 5, 2009)
Woody Harrelson’s “Zombieland” slays the competition, coming in #1 at the box office with $25 million. Meanwhile, “Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs” came in second place with $16.7 million and “Whip It” in sixth with a disappointing $4.8 million.
-
MovieMantz Reviews: ‘Capitalism: A Love Story’ & ‘Invention Of Lying’
You can always count on Michael Moore to stir up some controversy and he does just that with “Capitalism.” And, Ricky Gervais lives in a world where everyone tells the truth, and he invents “Lying”!
-
MovieMantz Reviews: The Best Of The Toronto Film Festival (September 25, 2009)
Scott “Movie” Mantz traveled up to the Toronto Film Festival and now he shares his favorite picks. Did George Clooney score with both “Up In the Air” and “The Men Who Stare At Goats”? Plus, which actress-turned-director has a hit on her hands?
-
Box Office Showdown: ‘Cloudy With A Chance Of’ #1 (September 21, 2009)
“Cloudy With a Chance of Meatballs” takes the #1 spot at the box office with over $30 million - but how much of that was from 3D? Meanwhile, Matt Damon’s “The Informant!” comes in second with just $10 million.
-
2009 Toronto Film Festival: Top Five Movies To See
Scott “Movie” Mantz and Hollywood.com’s Paul Dergarabedian run down the top five movies to check out at the Toronto Film Festival including Matt Damon in “The Informant” and George Clooney in “The Men Who Stare at Goats.”
-
Box Office Showdown: Was It A Record Breaking Summer? (September 8, 2009)
There were a ton of hit movies this summer, but did the box office break its previous revenue record? Plus, “The Final Destination” held on to the top spot for the second week in a row, while Brad Pitt’s “Inglourious Basterds” came in second. MovieMantz breaks it down
-
Box Office Showdown: ‘The Final Destination’ Kills The Competition (August 31, 2009)
The horror movie sequel, “The Final Destination,” opens number one at the box office with over $28 million. Brad Pitt’s “Inglourious Basterds” drops to second place with $20 million. Meanwhile, “Taking Woodstock” comes in ninth with just $3.7 million.
-
MovieMantz Review: ‘World’s Greatest Dad’ & ‘The September Issue’
Now that all the summer blockbusters are done, it’s time for the indie films to get their chance, including Robin Williams in “Worlds Greatest Dad!” And, if you’ve got a passion for fashion, check out “The September Issue.”
-
Box Office Showdown: ‘Inglourious Basterds’ Storms The Box Office (August 24, 2009)
Brad Pitt in Quentin Tarantino’s “Inglourious Basterds” takes the top spot at the box office with $37.6 million. Dropping to second place was last week’s champ, “District 9,” with $18.9 million, followed by “G.I. Joe” in third with $12.5 million.
-
MovieMantz Reviews: ‘Inglourious Basterds’ & ‘District 9’ (August 21, 2009)
Access’ Scott “Movie” Mantz gives glowing reviews to both “Inglourious Basterds” and “District 9,” but which film does he call an “instant classic”?
-
Box Office Showdown: ‘District 9’ Invades The Box Office (August 17, 2009)
“District 9,” which cost around $30 million to make, tops the box office with over $37 million. Coming in second place with $22.5 million was last week’s champ, “G.I. Joe: The Rise of Cobra,” followed by “The Time Traveler’s Wife” in third with $19.2 million.
-
Box Office Showdown: ‘G.I. Joe: The Rise Of Cobra’ Tops Box Office (August 10, 2009)
After not pre-screening for critics, “G.I. Joe: The Rise Of Cobra” tops the box office with just under $55 million. Meanwhile, “Julie & Julia” cooks up $20 million in second place with “G-Force” coming in third with just under $10 million.
-
Box Office Showdown: ‘G-Force’ Squeaks Its Way Up To #1 (July 27, 2009)
“G-Force” kicks butt at the box office, coming in number one with just under $32 million. “Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince” slips to second place with $29 million. And, the romantic comedy, “The Ugly Truth,” comes in third with $27 million.
-
Movie Mantz Weekend Review: ‘The Ugly Truth’ & ‘Orphan’ (July 24, 2009)
Access’ Scott “Movie” Mantz gives the lowdown on whether or not you should see this weekend’s new releases — “The Ugly Truth” and “Orphan.”
-
Box Office Showdown: ‘Harry Potter And The Half-Blood Prince’ Rules The Box Office (July 20, 2009)
“Harry Potter” cast a spell on audiences once again, this time breaking all records for midnight screenings and bringing in almost $160 million at the box office. Plus, “The Hangover” continues to hang on in the top five, breaking records for a comedy.
-
MovieMantz Review: '(500) Days Of Summer’ & ‘The Hurt Locker’ (July 17, 2009)
In “(500) Days of Summer,” Joseph Gordon-Levitt falls in love with Zooey Deschanel, but she doesn’t really fall back in love with him. Meanwhile, don’t think of “The Hurt Locker” as just another Iraq movie, it’s just a great movie — period.
-
MovieMantz Review: ‘The Proposal’
Scott “Movie” Mantz calls Sandra Bullock and Ryan Reynolds’ new romantic comedy, “The Proposal,” the sleeper hit of the summer, but thinks “Year One” is a one-joke movie that you most people may want to skip.
-
Box Office Showdown: ‘The Hangover’ Keeps Buzzing (June 15, 2009)
“The Hangover” holds on to the number one spot for the second week in a row with $32.7 million. Meanwhile, Pixar’s “Up” comes in second with $30.7 million while the action/thriller “The Taking of Pelham 1 2 3” comes in third with $23.3 million.
-
Box Office Showdown: ‘Up’ & ‘The Hangover’ Fight For Top Spot (June 8, 2009)
Pixar’s animated film “Up” and Warner Bros.’ new comedy, “The Hangover,” battle it out over the weekend for the top spot, but is it too close to call a winner? Plus, Will Ferrell’s “Land Of The Lost” underperforms, coming in third.
Rate this video: