Man Of Steel Review (MovieMantz)
June 14, 2013
LOS ANGELES, Calif. --
The super-serious tone robs “Man of Steel” from being the rousing, awe-inspiring and exciting good time that it should be…
“Man of Steel”
Starring: Henry Cavill, Amy Adams, Michael Shannon, Russell Crowe
Directed by: Zack Snyder
After giving Batman a much-needed makeover for the big screen that also returned the character to the darker tone of his comic book origins, it seemed only natural – or more likely, inevitable – that Warner Bros. Studios would turn to Christopher Nolan to polish the crown jewel of the DC Comics universe, who just so happens to be the most famous superhero of them all: Superman. But despite being released just in time for the Last Son of Krypton’s diamond 75th anniversary, “Man of Steel” proves that what may have given strength to one film series may have the effect of Kryptonite on another.
Not that Nolan serves in the same capacity here that he did on the “Dark Knight” trilogy (where he directed all three movies); he only co-produced “Man of Steel” and co-wrote the story with David S. Goyer (“Batman Begins,” “Blade”). Taking over the directing chores is Zack Snyder, whose success with the genre ranges from the awesome “300” (2007) to the underrated “Watchmen” (2009) to the abysmal “Sucker Punch” (2011). But it still feels more like a Nolan film than a Snyder one, thanks to a super-serious tone that turns out to be far too serious for its own good.
Therein lies the paradox between Batman and Superman. Batman is not a superhero with special powers. He’s a vigilante with deep psychological issues, so Nolan’s more realistic approach to the character served him well. By contrast, Superman is an alien who can fly, shoot heat beams from his eyes and is practically indestructible. So where the somber tone was a good fit for “The Dark Knight,” it robs “Man of Steel” from being the rousing, awe-inspiring and exciting good time that it should be.
After 75 years, you’d be hard-pressed to find anyone who isn’t even slightly familiar with the origin of Superman, who was created by Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster back in 1938 for the first issue of “Action Comics.” With his home planet of Krypton facing imminent destruction, Jor-El (Russell Crowe) sends his newborn son Kal-El across the heavens to Earth, where he will gain incredible powers. But while he is being raised by his adopted Midwestern parents Jonathan and Martha Kent (Kevin Costner and Diane Lane), Clark (Henry Cavill), as he is renamed, struggles with the burden of his purpose while facing off with another survivor from his old ‘hood, General Zod (Michael Shannon).
If Nolan’s presence invites comparisons between “Man of Steel” and “The Dark Knight,” then the character invites comparisons to the one that started it all: 1978’s “Superman: The Movie,” directed by Richard Donner. Here was a film that had it all, which is why it still stands as the gold standard for movies based on comic book characters. It was fun, exciting and magical. It had heart, humor and romance. It had an awesome villain (Lex Luthor, played with scene-chewing vitality by Gene Hackman). It had not one, but two fully dynamic performances by Christopher Reeve (as the heroic Superman and as his sweet, bumbling alter-ego Clark Kent). And lastly, who can forget that incredible score composed by John Williams?
Taken purely on its own terms, “Man of Steel” is fine. But for a movie about a man who can fly, anything less than superb qualifies as a disappointment. The cinematography is too dark, the tone is too heavy-handed, and Hans Zimmer’s score is too similar to “The Dark Knight” while lacking a standout “theme” for Superman. In addition, after 2006’s “Superman Returns” was widely criticized for not having enough action, “Man of Steel” overcompensates with CGI-heavy action scenes that go on too long, become redundant and look too much like those depicted in “Thor,” “The Matrix” and “The Avengers.”
And then there’s Henry Cavill, an actor who certainly looks the part while dressed up in his snazzy red-and-blue tights, but he plays Clark Kent in the same brooding manner in which he plays Superman. Michael Shannon fares better as the villainous General Zod, but even he pales in comparison to Terence Stamp’s unforgettable performance as Zod in 1981’s “Superman II.” Amy Adams feels somewhat miscast as Lois Lane and doesn’t have enough chemistry with Cavill, but leave it to Russell Crowe to steal the movie with his fully dynamic and passionate performance as Jor-El.
The filmmakers may have gone out of their way to distance themselves from “Superman Returns,” a love letter to the earlier Reeve movies that wore its heart a little too much on its sleeve. But by doing so, they’ve taken all the fun out of it. Where the tagline for the first “Superman” movie was “you’ll believe a man can fly,” the tagline for “Man of Steel” should be “you’ll believe a man can mope.” It’s just too heavy, and for a character that can leap tall buildings in a single bound, “Man of Steel” doesn’t leap far enough, proving that what worked for one film series doesn’t always work for another.
Verdict: SKIP IT!
-- Scott Mantz
Copyright 2013 by NBC Universal, Inc. All rights reserved.
This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
MovieMantz Reviews: Frozen, Black Nativity, Mandela: Long Walk To Freedom & Homefront
Scott “Movie” Mantz visits Access Hollywood Live to review the newest movies hitting theaters this holiday weekend. Did Disney’s “Frozen” warm Scott’s heart or leave him in the cold? Plus, how is Idris Elba’s performance as Nelson Mandela in “Mandela: Long Walk To Freedom”? And, are “Black Nativity” & “Homefront” worthy of a “See It” rating?
Holiday Film Preview: Which Movies Are Must Watch?
With a ton of holiday films still to come, Access’ Scott “Movie” Mantz and Fandango’s Dave Karger breakdown the must watch movies for the holiday season, including “Saving Mr. Banks,” “The Wolf of Wall Street” and “American Hustle.”
MovieMantz Reviews: Mandela – Long Walk To Freedom, Black Nativity & Homefront
Access’ Scott “Movie” Mantz calls Idris Elba’s new film, “Mandel: Long Walk to Freedom,” a “really powerful” movie. Also, why is “Black Nativity” so “hard to resist”? Plus, what does he have to say about Jason Statham’s new movie, “Homefront”?
MovieMantz Reviews: Disney’s Frozen & Nebraska
Access’ Scott “Movie” Mantz is calling Disney’s “Frozen” the perfect movie to see over the Thanksgiving weekend. Plus, why is Scott calling screen legend Bruce Dern’s role in “Nebraska” the performance of his career?
Idris Elba Discusses Mandela: Long Walk To Freedom & Oscar Buzz
Idris Elba talks with Access’ Scott “Movie” Mantz about the “relief” he felt for the positive reception he received for the Johannesburg premiere of his new movie, “Mandela: Long Walk to Freedom.” Also, he tells Scott about the “massive compliment” he received from Nelson Mandela’s wife, Winnie. Plus, how Idris feel about the Oscar buzz surrounding his film?
Naomie Harris’ Mandela: Long Walk To Freedom NYC Premiere
Naomie Harris chats with Access’ Scott “Movie” Mantz about how great it is to premiere her new film, “Mandela: Long Walk to Freedom,” in New York City. Also, she tells Scott how great it felt to have Winnie Mandela’s blessing. Plus, Naomie is extremely flattered by the Oscar buzz surrounding her and Idris’ performances.
MovieMantz Reviews: Thor: The Dark World & The Armstrong Lie
Access’ Scott “Movie” Mantz says he liked “Thor: The Dark World” more than its predecessor – but, did he like it enough to recommend seeing it? Plus, what does Scott think about “The Armstrong Lie,” a movie which details how Lance Armstrong duped the world.
MovieMantz Reviews: Thor: The Dark World & The Armstrong Lie
Scott “Movie” Mantz visits Access Hollywood Live to review this weekend’s newest releases. Is “Thor: The Dark World” another hit for the successful Marvel franchise or is it a dud? Plus, is the new documentary, “The Armstrong Lie,” which revisits the Lance Armstrong performance enhancing drug scandal, worth checking out?
Will Forte Takes On His First Serious Role In Nebraska
Will Forte tells Access’ Scott “Movie” Mantz why it was so “nerve racking” taking on his first serious role in “Nebraska.” Plus, he chats about bonding with director Alexander Payne over margaritas. So, how did he connect with co-star Bruce Dern?
Jaimie Alexander Dishes On Her Revealing Dress - Thor: The Dark World Hollywood Premiere
Jaimie Alexander chats with Access’ Scott “Movie” Mantz about getting ready for the Hollywood premiere of “Thor: The Dark World.” How difficult was it to put on her revealing dress? What’s the secret to keeping it on? Plus, why does she think that “Thor” is the sexiest superhero of them all?
Stan Lee Talks The Amazing Spider-Man 2 Cameo: How Will This One Be Different?
Stan Lee chats with Access’ Scott “Movie” Mantz at the Hollywood premiere of “Thor: The Dark World” about the big bucks the film has already made overseas, before the movie has opened in the US. Plus, what can he reveal about his cameo in “The Amazing Spider-Man 2”?
Kat Dennings Talks Bringing The Humor To Thor: The Dark World
Kat Dennings chats with Access’ Scott “Movie” Mantz at the Hollywood premiere of “Thor: The Dark World” about helping to bring the humor to the movie. Plus, why does she say the movie’s action and romance will be enjoyed by both men and women?
Zachary Levi Talks Joining The Cast Of Thor: The Dark World
Zachary Levi chats with Access’ Scott “Movie” Mantz at the Hollywood premiere of “Thor: The Dark World.” How excited was he to join the cast? Plus, why does he think this movie is so popular with the Marvel fans?
Clark Gregg Talks Bringing The Marvel Universe Together On Agents Of S.H.E.I.L.D.
Clark Gregg chats with Access’ Scott “Movie” Mantz at the Hollywood premiere of “Thor: The Dark World” about his journey through the Marvel universe. How exciting has it been to be a part of this world? Plus, will “Thor” make an appearance on ABC’s “Agents of S.H.E.I.L.D.”?
Tom Hiddleston Reveals His Latest Impression: Anthony Hopkins!
Anthony Hopkins Dishes On Thor: The Dark World & His Breaking Bad Obsession
Anthony Hopkins brings his family to the premiere of this new movie, “Thor: The Dark World,” at the El Capitan Theatre where he praises the entire cast to Access’ Scott “Movie” Mantz. Also, he talks about the phone call he got from Bryan Cranston after he received his “Breaking Bad” fan letter.
Chris Hemsworth’s Thor: The Dark World Hollywood Premiere
Chris Hemsworth talks with Access’ Scott “Movie” Mantz about the box office success of this new film, “Thor: The Dark World.” Also, how did he film his kiss scenes with co-star Natalie Portman, who is a foot shorter than him? Plus, Chris tells Scott how Mike Tyson inspired his fighting style in the Marvel movie.
MovieMantz Reviews: Dallas Buyers Club, Ender’s Game & Free Birds
Access movie critic Scott “Movie” Mantz says Matthew McConaughey gives the performance of his career as Ron Woodroof in “Dallas Buyers Club” — but what did he think of Jared Leto’s work? Plus, what did he think of Harrison Ford in “Ender’s Game”? And, what does Scott think about Owen Wilson’s new animated movie, “Free Birds”?
Last Vegas, Dallas Buyers Club, About Time, Free Birds & Ender’s Game – MovieMantz Reviews
Scott “Movie” Mantz reviews five movies at a frenetic pace on Access Hollywood Live. MovieMantz will let you know where to spend your box office bucks this weekend in no time flat!
The Counselor & Blue Is The Warmest Color – MovieMantz Reviews
Access’ Scott “Movie” Mantz weighs in on this weekend’s new releases. Why wasn’t he a fan of “The Counselor,” despite the all-star cast? Plus, Scott reviews the foreign film “Blue is the Warmest Color.”
Bad Grandpa & The Counselor – MovieMantz Reviews
Access Hollywood’s Scott “Movie” Mantz gets ornery as his alter-ego “Grandpa Mantz” to review “Jackass Presents: Bad Grandpa” & the new Michael Fassbender and Brad Pitt thriller “The Counselor.” Are these new films worth watching? “Grandpa Mantz” will give his verdict if he doesn’t get kicked off the set first!
MovieMantz Reviews: 12 Years A Slave & All Is Lost
Access movie critic Scott “Movie” Mantz calls “12 Years a Slave” a “masterpiece,” but is it Best Picture material? And if so, can it beat “Gravity”? Plus, while Scott calls Robert Redford’s performance in “All Is Lost” “remarkable,” does he think it can be a contender?
MovieMantz Reviews: Captain Phillips; The Inevitable Defeat Of Mister & Pete
While Access’ Scott “Movie” Mantz thinks Tom Hanks’ new movie, “Captain Phillips,” has all the makings of a great movie – why is he saying the film has some issues? Plus, what does he think of Jennifer Hudson’s new flick, “The Inevitable Defeat of Mister & Pete”?
Chloe Grace Moretz’s Carrie Premiere
Chloe Grace Moretz discusses why “Carrie” is “more relevant” today with Access’ Scott “Movie” Mantz at the premiere in Los Angeles. Plus, she talks about why she didn’t want to know when the bucket of blood would fall on her when she filmed the movie’s iconic prom scene. So, what was it like being covered in fake blood?
MovieMantz Reviews: Gravity & Rush
Access’ Scott “Movie” Mantz calls “Gravity” a “movie experience like no other,” but would he see it again? Plus, why is Scott calling “Rush” one of director Ron Howard’s “best movies in years”?
All Is Lost Review (MovieMantz)
Captain Phillips Review (MovieMantz)
Enough Said Review (MovieMantz)
Gravity Review (MovieMantz)
Toronto Film Festival Roundup: 7 Must-See Movies (MovieMantz)
Star Trek Into Darkness Fans Boldly Set the Record Straight
Blue Jasmine Review (MovieMantz)
Star Trek Into Darkness: Is It Really The Worst Star Trek Movie Ever? (MovieMantz)
Europa Report Review (MovieMantz)
The Wolverine Review (MovieMantz)
The Way, Way Back Review (MovieMantz)
White House Down Review (MovieMantz)
World War Z Review (MovieMantz)
Man Of Steel Review (MovieMantz)
The Hangover Part III Review: The Party’s Over (MovieMantz)
Star Trek Into Darkness Review (MovieMantz)
Iron Man 3 Review (MovieMantz)
42 Review (MovieMantz)
Oscar Predictions 2013: Who Will Win/Who Should Win (MovieMantz)
Top 10 Movies Of 2012 (MovieMantz)
This Is 40 Review (MovieMantz)
Zero Dark Thirty Review (MovieMantz)
Life Of Pi — MovieMantz Review
The Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn - Part 2 Review (MovieMantz)
Lincoln Review (MovieMantz)
Top 10 Baseball Movies Of All-Time (MovieMantz)
Access’ Scott “Movie” Mantz countsdown the top 10 baseball movies of all-time. Play ball!
Top 10 Movies Of 2012 (MovieMantz)
Access’ Scott ‘Movie’ Mantz counts down the best movies of 2012!
MovieMantz: Top 10 Christmas Movies Of All-Time
Access’ Scott “Movie” Mantz breaks down his top 10 favorite Christmas movies of all-time, with some titles that you might not expect!
MovieMantz 2011 Oscar Predictions: And The Oscar Will Go To…
Who will walk away a winner on Hollywood’s biggest night? Access’ Scott “Movie” Mantz weighs in with his predictions!
MovieMantz: Oscar Predictions 2010 — ‘It’s Complicated? Hardly!’
Who will walk away a winner on Oscar night this year? Access’ Scott “Movie” Mantz weighs in with his predictions!
MovieMantz: Best Movies of the Decade
Find out which films made MovieMantz’s list!
MovieMantz: Best of 2009
For the first time in a while, I actually had a hard time picking just 10 movies for my annual year-end best-of list. Ah, if I only had this problem every year…
MovieMantz Countdown: Top 10 Scariest Movies of All Time
Access’ Scott “Movie” Mantz counts down the top 10 horror films of all time!