MovieMantz Review: ‘Dear John’ & ‘Edge Of Darkness’
“Dear John” is based on the book by Nicholas Sparks, who also wrote “The Notebook.” But, does Scott “Movie” Mantz think it’s better than “The Notebook”? And will the latest controversy surrounding Mel Gibson keep audiences from enjoying his new movie?
MovieMantz Rantz: Where No Beatle Has Gone Before!
1/2
-
WireImage
Paul McCartney with ‘Star Trek’ stars John Cho, Chris Pine, Anton Yelchin, Zachary Quinto and composer Michael Giacchino during the 15th annual Critics’ Choice Movie Awards held at the Hollywood Palladium on January 15, 2010 in Hollywood
-
WireImage
Paul McCartney and Nancy Shevell attend the 15th Annual Critics’ Choice Movie Awards at The Paladium on January 15, 2010 in Hollywood
FIRST PUBLISHED: January 18, 2010 2:39 PM EST
LOS ANGELES, Calif. --
If there’s anything I love as much as “Star Trek,” it’s The Beatles – and, of course, my awesome wife of two months, Andrea. In one amazing night, they all came together, and I actually had something to do with it.
The night was Friday, January 15, 2010, and the place was the Hollywood Palladium. That’s where the 15th Annual Critics Choice Movie Awards took place, and as member of the Broadcast Film Critics Association – the voting organization behind the ceremony – I got to go.
I knew it was going to be a great night earlier that week. That’s when my friend and publicity colleague at Paramount called to tell me the great news: that I was sitting with Chris Pine, Zachary Quinto and other cast members and producers at the “Star Trek” table.
Now, it’s no secret that I loved the movie on two levels – as a fan of “Star Trek” and as a fan of movies – but the prospect of sitting with these guys at a black-tie awards gala was too good to be true. But when it occurred to me that my favorite Beatle, Paul McCartney, might also be there – since he was nominated for Best Original Song, called “(I Want to) Come Home,” from “Everybody’s Fine” – I thought I was going to spontaneously combust.
By the time I got to my table, the ceremony – which aired live on VH1 – was just starting. The “Trek” crew, including Pine (Kirk), Quinto (Spock), John Cho (Sulu) and Anton Yelchin (Chekov), all remembered my enthusiastic junket interviews last spring, where it was, to put it mildly, really obvious that I loved the movie.
It didn’t take long to see where Paul was sitting – right next to the stage with his girlfriend, Nancy Shevell. He didn’t have a lot of people swarming around him, so at the next commercial break, I went for it – I grabbed Andrea’s hand and made a beeline for Paul.
As we walked over to Paul’s table, he saw us coming and got up to say hello.
Scott: Hi, Paul, I’m Scott.
Paul: Hello, Scott!
Scott: This is my wife, Andrea. We got married last November, and our song – our first dance – was to “My Love.”
Paul (obviously touched): Oh, congratulations (gives Scott and Andrea a group hug!).
Andrea: But wait, Scott, tell him what we walked down the aisle to!
Scott: “And I Love Her.”
Andrea: And after the ceremony, we walked out to?
Scott: “I Want to Hold Your Hand.”
After Paul introduced us to Nancy, I showed him that I was wearing a Beatles watch. That’s when it hit him that I was a Beatlemaniac.
Paul (to Andrea, but pointing at me): So, how are you holding up with this?
Andrea (laughing): He’s just really passionate.
Scott: Hey, so, when are you playing in LA again?
Paul: We’re still planning it, but hopefully sometime this year.
Scott: Yessss!
Paul: Well, just be good. Be good to each other, and love each other.
Scott: Thanks, Paul, have a good night!
With that, we walked back to our table, having just received a blessing from The Cute One. We sat back down, and still blown away after that surreal encounter, I told the “Star Trek” guys about it. They got really excited and asked where he was sitting. I tried pointing him out to them, but when they couldn’t see him, I walked them over to him.
Paul got up to meet them, and that’s when I realized that I just brought my two biggest worlds together: “Star Trek” and The Beatles. Then they came back to the table and were just ask excited as I was.
But here’s the beauty of it. I wasn’t at the Critics Choice Movie Awards because I was working. I was there because I belonged there, and for four unforgettable minutes, I had Paul all to myself. No one else was waiting to talk to him, he was engaged in our conversation, and he was obviously moved that one of his songs played such an important part at our wedding. He was totally gracious and couldn’t have been any nicer.
Not to mention that the “Star Trek” guys were totally cool, friendly and down-to-earth too. Not sure if I will ever top that night, but who’s thinking that far ahead? I’m still reeling from the advice I got from Paul, which, of course, comes down to the Beatles mantra: All You Need is Love.
Copyright 2009 by NBC Universal, Inc. All rights reserved.
This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Keep your Access to everything in Hollywood! Breaking news and personal commentary from Billy, Tony, Shaun, Maria & all of our producers! Follow us on Facebook and Twitter now!
MovieMantz: Best Movies of the Decade
I spent so much time obsessing over my annual Top 10 list of the best movies of the year, it never even occurred to me that an even more important task was at hand: to compile the best movies of the decade. (Wow, where on earth did the last ten years go?) Now, conventional wisdom would dictate that coming up with that list would be pretty easy: simply take the number one movie for each of the last ten years, and there you go: ten movies. But there are two factors that must be taken into consideration. For one thing, some years were stronger than others, resulting in a situation where, say, the 8th best movie of 2004 was actually stronger than the 1st best movie of 2003. Then there’s the benefit of hindsight. Some movies simply get better with age, while others, well, don’t. With that in mind, I decided to take a shot at listing what are, in my opinion, the best movies of the decade. Some of my choices may surprise you. Heck, they surprised even me.
More Videos
-
MovieMantz Review: ‘Dear John’ & ‘Edge Of Darkness’
“Dear John” is based on the book by Nicholas Sparks, who also wrote “The Notebook.” But, does Scott “Movie” Mantz think it’s better than “The Notebook”? And will the latest controversy surrounding Mel Gibson keep audiences from enjoying his new movie?
-
MovieMantz Review: ‘Cyrus,’ ‘Frozen’ & ‘Welcome To The Riley’s’
Scott “Movie” Mantz reviews some of the big draws from this year’s Sundance Film Festival — “Cyrus,” “Frozen” and “Welcome to the Riley’s.” But which of these films does he think you will love and which ones should you leave alone?
-
MovieMantz Weekend Review: ‘Invictus’ & ‘Up In The Air’
‘Invictus’ has the recipe for success with Clint Eastwood directing and Matt Damon and Morgan Freeman starring, but did Scott “Movie” Mantz like it? Plus, why does Scott say “Up In The Air” is the movie to beat?
-
MovieMantz Review: ‘Avatar’ & ‘Crazy Heart’
There’s no question that James Cameron knows how to break ground with special effects, but how does the story in “Avatar” match up? Plus, why is Scott “Movie” Mantz calling “Crazy Heart’s” story “really predictable”?
-
MovieMantz Reviews: ‘The Lovely Bones’ & ‘The Book Of Eli’
Why does Scott “Movie” Mantz say that Peter Jackson’s “The Lovely Bones” feels like a low-budget indie? And, what does he mean by that? Plus, what did he think about the post-apocalyptic world of “The Book Of Eli,” starring Denzel Washington?
-
The Final 45 (January 8, 2010)
Garth Brooks teamed up his Garth Brooks Teammates for Kids Foundation with the Professional Bull Riders Association. Plus, Access’ very own Scott “Movie” Mantz receives his third consecutive press award nomination from the Publicist Guild!
-
MovieMantz Reviews: ‘Youth In Revolt’ & ‘The Young Victoria’
Michael Cera plays a love-struck teen trying to lose his virginity in “Youth In Revolt,” but is he able to break the mold with this character? Plus, did Scott “Movie” Mantz find “The Young Victoria” to be pretentious or entertaining?
-
Access Fanboys Geek Out Over Katee Sackhoff
AccessHollywood.com’s Laura Saltman surprises “Battlestar Galactica” alum Katee Sackhoff with a few of her biggest fans including Access’ own Scott “Movie” Mantz.
-
MovieMantz Review: ‘New Moon’ & ‘The Blind Side’
Access’ Scott “Movie” Mantz calls “New Moon” flawed, cheesy and slow paced - but should he even be reviewing this movie? And, find out why Scott is calling Sandra Bullock’s new movie, “The Blind Side,” terrific!
-
‘Star Trek’ DVD Release Party: J.J. Abrams On The ‘Trek’ Sequel & ‘Lost’ Final Season
Director J.J. Abrams talks with Scott “Movie” Mantz about why he made some of the choices he did on his reinvisioning of “Star Trek.” Plus, what does he have planned for the sequel? And, what does he reveal about the final season of “Lost”?
-
‘Star Trek’ DVD Release Party: Zachary Quinto On The ‘Trek’ Sequel
Zachary Quinto talks with Access’ Scott “Movie” Mantz about how excited he is to get the crew back together for the next movie. Plus, how does he think the destruction of Vulcan is going to affect his character, Spock, in the next film?
-
‘Star Trek’ DVD Release Party: Leonard Nimoy & Walter Koenig Talk ‘Trek’
Leonard Nimoy reveals what he was trying to say when his character, Spock, said “thrusters on full” in the last scene of the movie. Plus, what did Walter Koenig think the first time he saw the movie?
-
John Cho On ‘Star Trek’ Oscar Campaign & ‘Sexiest Leading Man’ Award
At the DVD launch party for “Star Trek,” John Cho (Sulu) toys with the idea of starting an Oscar campaign for “Star Trek.” Plus, whom does he nominate for a “Sexiest Leading Man” award? And, does he dish on sequel rumors?
-
MovieMantz Review: ‘2012,’ ‘The Fantastic Mr. Fox’ & ‘Dare!’
From the director of “Independence Day” comes the action packed “2012,” but why is Scott “Movie” Mantz calling this film a disaster? Plus, a quick look at George Clooney in the animated “The Fantastic Mr. Fox” & the indie film “Dare!”
-
MovieMantz Reviews: Michael Jackson’s ‘This Is It’
Access’ Scott “Movie” Mantz takes on Michael Jackson’s highly anticipated “This Is It” film. Was this movie fit for a King?
-
MovieMantz Reviews: ‘Amelia’, ‘Astro Boy’ & More (October 23, 2009)
Access’ Scott “Movie” Mantz takes on a whole slew of films opening this weekend from “Amelia” to “An Education” to “Astro Boy” and more, but which ones get his seal of approval?
-
Box Office Showdown: A ‘Wild’ Weekend At The Box Office (October 19, 2009)
“Where The Wild Things Are” ruled the box office, coming in #1 with over $32 million. Meanwhile, Jamie Foxx and Gerard Butler’s “Law Abiding Citizen” came in second with over $21 million and “Paranormal Activity” was third with over $19 million.
-
MovieMantz Review: ‘Paranormal Activity’ & ‘Where The Wild Things Are’ (10/17/09)
Scott “Movie” Mantz says that “Paranormal Activity” is one of the best scary movies that he has seen in a long time - so will you be able to sleep after seeing it? Meanwhile, Scott found “Where The Wild Things Are” to be a bit depressing, but should you still see it?
-
Oren Peli’s ‘Paranormal Activity’ Is A Fright Fest
Director Oren Peli talks with Access about his movie, “Paranormal Activity,” and how “The Blair Witch Project” inspired him. Plus, what suggestions did Steven Spielberg give Oren about the ending of the film?
-
MovieMantz Reviews: ‘Paranormal Activity’ & ‘Couples Retreat’
Scott “Movie” Mantz is calling “Paranormal Activity” the scariest movie he’s seen in a long time. But, he thinks that Vince Vaughn’s comedy, “Couples Retreat,” is scary for a whole other reason.
-
Box Office Showdown: ‘Zombieland’ Kills The Competition (October 5, 2009)
Woody Harrelson’s “Zombieland” slays the competition, coming in #1 at the box office with $25 million. Meanwhile, “Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs” came in second place with $16.7 million and “Whip It” in sixth with a disappointing $4.8 million.
-
MovieMantz Reviews: ‘Capitalism: A Love Story’ & ‘Invention Of Lying’
You can always count on Michael Moore to stir up some controversy and he does just that with “Capitalism.” And, Ricky Gervais lives in a world where everyone tells the truth, and he invents “Lying”!
-
MovieMantz Reviews: The Best Of The Toronto Film Festival (September 25, 2009)
Scott “Movie” Mantz traveled up to the Toronto Film Festival and now he shares his favorite picks. Did George Clooney score with both “Up In the Air” and “The Men Who Stare At Goats”? Plus, which actress-turned-director has a hit on her hands?
-
Box Office Showdown: ‘Cloudy With A Chance Of’ #1 (September 21, 2009)
“Cloudy With a Chance of Meatballs” takes the #1 spot at the box office with over $30 million - but how much of that was from 3D? Meanwhile, Matt Damon’s “The Informant!” comes in second with just $10 million.
-
2009 Toronto Film Festival: Top Five Movies To See
Scott “Movie” Mantz and Hollywood.com’s Paul Dergarabedian run down the top five movies to check out at the Toronto Film Festival including Matt Damon in “The Informant” and George Clooney in “The Men Who Stare at Goats.”
More Articles
-
MovieMantz Rantz: Where No Beatle Has Gone Before!
-
MovieMantz: Golden Globe Predictions — They’re ‘Up In The Air’!
-
MovieMantz Rantz: ‘Spider-Man 4’ No More
-
MovieMantz: Best Movies Of The Decade
-
MovieMantz Review: ‘It’s Complicated’
-
MovieMantz Review: ‘Avatar’
-
MovieMantz: Best Films Of 2009 (‘The Best Of Times, the Worst Of Times’)
-
MovieMantz Review: ‘Up in the Air’
-
MovieMantz Review: ‘The Twilight Saga: New Moon’
-
MovieMantz Review: ‘2012’
-
MovieMantz Review: ‘Disney’s A Christmas Carol’
-
MovieMantz: Top 10 Baseball Movies Of All-Time
-
MovieMantz Review: ‘This Is It’
-
MovieMantz Review: ‘An Education’
-
MovieMantz Review: ‘Where the Wild Things Are’
-
MovieMantz Review: ‘Paranormal Activity’
-
MovieMantz Review: ‘Capitalism: A Love Story’
-
MovieMantz Review: ‘Up In The Air’
-
MovieMantz Review: ‘Surrogates’
-
MovieMantz Review: ‘All About Steve’
-
MovieMantz Review: ‘The September Issue’
-
MovieMantz Review: ‘Inglourious Basterds’
-
MovieMantz Review: ‘District 9’
-
MovieMantz Review: ‘Funny People’
-
MovieMantz Review: '(500) Days of Summer’
More Galleries
-
MovieMantz: Best Movies of the Decade
Find out which films made MovieMantz’s list!
-
MovieMantz: Best of 2009
For the first time in a while, I actually had a hard time picking just 10 movies for my annual year-end best-of list. Ah, if I only had this problem every year…
-
MovieMantz: Top 10 Baseball Movies Of All-Time
Access’ Scott “Movie” Mantz countsdown the top 10 baseball movies of all-time. Play ball!
-
MovieMantz Countdown: Top 10 Scariest Movies of All Time
ScottMantz breaks down the top 10 horror films of all time!
Rate this video: