Oscar Predictions 2013: Who Will Win/Who Should Win (MovieMantz)
FIRST PUBLISHED: February 8, 2013 1:35 PM EST
LAST UPDATED: February 22, 2013 11:36 AM EST
LOS ANGELES, Calif. --
I feel like I’ve been following the Academy Awards since I started breathing, but I simply cannot remember the last time Oscar pundits, analysts, bloggers, fans, nerds, whatever, went into such a tizzy over not just one, but two glaring omissions from the coveted list of nominees – and we’re not even talking about omissions from any of the high-profile acting categories.
I am, of course, referring to Ben Affleck and Kathryn Bigelow, who were infamously, shamelessly, disgracefully snubbed as Best Director for “Argo” and “Zero Dark Thirty,” respectively, despite the fact that both fact-based masterworks topped numerous year-end “Best of” lists from critics (mine included) and even started winning some awards back in late-December (especially for Bigelow). I mean, how dare they?
But right after New Year’s, the tide changed – and mighty fast – for “Argo.”
Just hours after being passed over by the Academy in the early hours of January 10, a vindicated Ben Affleck took the stage at the Critics’ Choice Movie Awards to collect his first statue of the season for Best Director (“Argo” won Best Picture too). In an all-too-obvious dig, Affleck addressed the elephant in the room by thanking “the Academy” just seconds after he bounced up to the podium (he was joking, maybe).
And that was just the first of many stops on what has turned out to be Affleck’s “Argo-F**k Yourself Redemption Tour.” In the days that followed, “Argo” won Best Director and Best Picture at the Golden Globes, it won Best Picture again at the Producers Guild Awards and it even trumped the presumed victor “Silver Linings Playbook” to win Best Acting Ensemble at the Screen Actors Guild Awards.
The icing on the cake came from his peers at the Directors Guild, which also named him Best Director. So while all of these back-to-back victories much have taken some – but let’s face it, not all – of the sting out of his snub, this groundswell of support for Affleck has become a blessing in disguise for “Argo,” which has now emerged as the movie to beat for Best Picture at the Academy Awards.
To that extent, that makes at least one of the categories easy to predict on my annual Oscar predictions list.
As for the others, there could be a few upsets, but I stand by my predictions. Hopefully you will too – and if you don’t, well, then “Argo-f**k yourself.”
BEST ANIMATED FEATURE:
The Nominees: “Brave,” “Frankenweenie,” “ParaNorman,” “The Pirates! Band of Misfits,” “Wreck-It Ralph”
The Breakdown: Major kudos to Disney for leading a strong year for animated films, three of which are nominated here. But where Disney-Pixar has dominated this field in years past, its latest offering, “Brave,” lacked the ingenious touch of previous gems like “Up” and “Toy Story 3.” Tim Burton’s “Frankenweenie” may resonate with Academy voters who will appreciate the nods to classic horror films, but “Wreck-It Ralph” is the cleverest of the bunch by far, since it did for 80s video game characters what “Toy Story” did for, well, toys.
Should Win: “Wreck-It Ralph”
Will Win: “Wreck-It Ralph”
BEST DOCUMENTARY FEATURE:
The Nominees: “5 Broken Cameras,” “The Gatekeepers,” “How to Survive a Plague,” “The Invisible War,” “Searching for Sugar Man”
The Breakdown: All strong contenders to be sure, but “Searching for Sugar Man” takes the cake for its crowd-pleasing and rousing stranger-than-fiction story about the resurrection of Rodriguez – a long-lost singer-songwriter from the 70s who finally got the long-overdue fame and recognition that he deserved.
Should Win: “Searching for Sugar Man”
Will Win: “Searching for Sugar Man”
BEST FOREIGN LANGUAGE FILM:
The Nominees: “Amour,” “Kon-Tiki,” “No,” “A Royal Affair,” “War Witch”
The Breakdown: With strong showings in four other major categories (including Best Picture and Best Director), Michael Haneke’s gripping emotional drama about a long-married couple facing the ravages of old age is a lock for Best Foreign Film.
Should Win: “Amour”
Will Win: “Amour”
BEST ADAPTED SCREENPLAY:
The Nominees: Chris Terrio (“Argo”), Lucy Alibar & Benh Zeitlin (“Beasts of the Southern Wild”), David Magee (“Life of Pi”), Tony Kushner (“Lincoln”), David O. Russell (“Silver Linings Playbook”)
The Breakdown: For a low-budget sensation like “Beasts of the Southern Wild” to get nominated for four Academy Awards, the nominations will have to serve as the prize (including this one). But it’s strange that Chris Terrio’s screenplay for “Argo” doesn’t have the frontrunner status that it deserves, since it has so many great one-liners. Then again, David O. Russell’s beautiful screenplay for “Silver Linings Playbook” is an actor’s dream that features so many profound, funny and touching moments, but Tony Kushner’s dense screenplay for “Lincoln” weaves a true ensemble of history’s finest characters, and it will likely pick up the slack here after losing steam in the Best Picture and Best Director categories.
Should Win: David O. Russell (“Silver Linings Playbook”)
Will Win: Tony Kushner (“Lincoln”)
BEST ORIGINAL SCREENPLAY:
The Nominees: Michael Haneke (“Amour”), Quentin Tarantino (“Django Unchained”), John Gatins (“Flight”), Wes Anderson & Roman Coppola (“Moonrise Kingdom”), Mark Boal (“Zero Dark Thirty”)
The Breakdown: “Zero Dark Thirty” bolted out of the gate last December by reaping enormous critical praise, only to face controversy over its allegedly favorable depiction of using torture to hunt down Osama bin Laden. Support for this proficient masterwork has sadly since waned, but there’s no denying its visceral impact (especially in the last 40 minutes). Mark Boal’s meticulous screenplay is the backbone of Kathryn Bigelow’s gripping thriller, but older Academy voters might be more drawn to the personal ordeal depicted in Michael Haneke’s emotionally powerful “Amour.”
Should Win: Mark Boal (“Zero Dark Thirty”)
Will Win: Michael Haneke (“Amour”)
BEST SUPPORTING ACTRESS:
The Nominees: Amy Adams (“The Master”), Sally Field (“Lincoln”), Anne Hathaway (“Les Miserables”), Helen Hunt (“The Sessions”), Jacki Weaver (“Silver Linings Playbook”)
The Breakdown: If there’s a sure thing in any of the acting categories, it’s Anne Hathaway for “Les Miserables.” And that comes down to a single scene: her one-take performance of “I Dreamed a Dream,” which is comparable to Jennifer Hudson’s show-stopping performance of “And I Am Telling You I’m Not Going,” which won her the Best Supporting Actress Oscar for 2006’s “Dreamgirls.”
Should Win: Anne Hathaway (“Les Miserables”)
Will Win: Anne Hathaway (“Les Miserables”)
BEST SUPPORTING ACTOR:
The Nominees: Alan Arkin (“Argo”), Robert De Niro (“Silver Linings Playbook”), Philip Seymour Hoffman (“The Master”), Tommy Lee Jones (“Lincoln”), Christoph Waltz (“Django Unchained”)
The Breakdown: How there could be any debate in a category that features Philip Seymour Hoffman’s brilliant performance as the complex cult leader Lancaster Dodd in “The Master” is beyond me. But even though it sure is nice to see Robert De Niro back in fine form as a football-obsessed father in “Silver Linings Playbook,” the tide does seem to be leaning more towards Tommy Lee Jones’ scene stealing turn as Thaddeus Stevens in “Lincoln” (especially after his victory at the SAG Awards).
Should Win: Philip Seymour Hoffman (“The Master”)
Will Win: Tommy Lee Jones (“Lincoln”)
BEST ACTRESS:
The Nominees: Jessica Chastain (“Zero Dark Thirty”), Jennifer Lawrence (“Silver Linings Playbook”), Emmanuelle Riva (“Amour”), Quvenzhane Wallis (“Beasts of the Southern Wild”), Naomi Watts (“The Impossible”)
The Breakdown: In a category that features both the youngest-ever acting nominee (Quvenzhane Wallis: 9) and the oldest (Emmanuelle Riva: 85), look for a possible upset here from the latter, especially if Academy voters sympathize with her ailing character in “Amour.” But while Naomi Watts should win based on the power of her grueling turn as a tsunami survivor in “The Impossible,” 22-year-old Jennifer Lawrence exudes the spirit of an old soul while giving a strong, vulnerable and heartbreaking performance in “Silver Linings Playbook.” And since “Silver Linings” is the first movie since 1981’s “Reds” to feature nominations in all four acting categories, it has to win at least one of them. (Doesn’t it?)
Should Win: Naomi Watts (“The Impossible”)
Will Win: Jennifer Lawrence (“Silver Linings Playbook”)
BEST ACTOR:
The Nominees: Bradley Cooper (“Silver Linings Playbook”), Daniel Day-Lewis (“Lincoln”), Hugh Jackman (“Les Miserables”), Joaquin Phoenix (“The Master”), Denzel Washington (“Flight”)
The Breakdown: So, it’s all about Daniel Day-Lewis’ monumental turn as the 16th President of the USA, right? Well, not so fast. Sure, Day-Lewis successfully managed to humanize an iconic figure like Honest Abe, but don’t rule out Hugh Jackman, who not only gave a tremendous physical and emotional performance in “Les Miserables,” but did so while singing the whole darn thing live – no small feat, and one that’s bound to resonate with Academy voters (and besides, Day-Lewis already has two Best Actor Oscars, while Jackman has none). But “Les Miserables” got otherwise mixed reviews and, well, Daniel Day-Lewis simply is Lincoln. More than anything, the film succeeds by depicting what it must have really been like to have been in his presence.
Should Win: Daniel Day-Lewis (“Lincoln”)
Will Win: Daniel Day-Lewis (“Lincoln”)
BEST DIRECTOR:
The Nominees: Michael Haneke (“Amour”), Benh Zeitlin (“Beasts of the Southern Wild”), Ang Lee (“Life of Pi”), Steven Spielberg (“Lincoln”), David O. Russell (“Silver Linings Playbook”)
The Breakdown: Well, well, well! What to do about a category where the person who should win (and probably would have won) wasn’t even nominated? Okay, we’ve already addressed this, but suffice to say that Best Director now comes down to two people: one who turned a seemingly unfilmable best-selling novel into a breathtaking, groundbreaking, beautiful and emotionally profound 3-D masterpiece, and one who made an “important” film that will find a permanent home in American History classes ‘til the end of time. Look for the Oscar to go to the latter, since “Lincoln” has to win one of the top two big awards, and it sure as heck won’t be Best Picture.
Should Win: Ang Lee (“Life of Pi”)
Will Win: Steven Spielberg (“Lincoln”)
BEST PICTURE:
The Nominees: “Amour,” “Argo,” “Beasts of the Southern Wild,” “Django Unchained,” “Les Miserables,” “Life of Pi,” “Lincoln,” “Silver Linings Playbook,” “Zero Dark Thirty”
The Breakdown: Aaaand, we’re back. Even though I laid out my argument for why “Argo” will win Best Picture at the top of this article, here’s why it should win: it’s the best movie of the year, period. “Argo” has it all: drama, suspense, satire, humor, excitement, a fascinating (and still-relevant) true story, fully-realized characters and a rousing finale. What more do you want from a Best Picture?
Should Win: “Argo”
Will Win: “Argo”
-- Scott Mantz
Copyright 2013 by NBC Universal, Inc. All rights reserved.
This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
For breaking news and personal commentary from our hosts and producers, follow us on Facebook and Twitter!
More Articles
Seth MacFarlane Won’t Return As 2014 Oscar Host
Mo’Nique Reveals 80 Pound Weight Loss
Catherine Zeta-Jones Checks Into Mental Health Facility For Treatment Of Bipolar Disorder
Seth MacFarlane Asked Back To Host Oscars? (Updated)
Oscar Producers Zadan, Meron To Return In 2014
Robert Downey Jr.‘s Oscar Guarantee: I’ll Win ‘At Least One’
Jennifer Garner Explains Ben Affleck’s Oscar Speech: It Was The ‘Warmest Compliment’
Academy Announces Oscars Dates For 2014, 2015
Jennifer Lawrence Debuts New Big Blond Hair On Set Of David O. Russell Project (First Look)
Will Smith Explains Turning Down Django Unchained: ‘I Need To Be The Lead’
Jennifer Lawrence’s Oscars Look: 7 Days Of Beauty At The Oscars (#1)
Geena Davis Slams Seth MacFarlane’s Oscars Routine
Bradley Cooper: ‘I Don’t Want To Win An Oscar’
Glam Slam: Makeup Mondays — The Zoe Saldana Edition
Catherine Zeta-Jones’ Oscars Look: 7 Days Of Beauty At The Oscars (#2)
Sandra Bullock’s Oscars Look: 7 Days Of Beauty At The Oscars (#3)
Anne Hathaway’s Oscars Look: 7 Days Of Beauty At The Oscars (#5)
First Lady Not Surprised By Reaction To Her Oscars Appearance
ROLL CALL: Jane Fonda Slams Seth MacFarlane’s ‘We Saw Your Boobs’ Oscars Song
Kristen Stewart’s Oscars Look: 7 Days Of Beauty At The Oscars (#6)
Glam Slam: Halle Berry & Jennifer Aniston: Oscar’s Lovely Ladies
Jessica Chastain’s Oscars Look: 7 Days Of Beauty At The Oscars (#7)
Oscars 2014 – Who Should Host?
Donald Trump Explains Why He Called Django Unchained ‘Racist’ In Tweet
Tina Fey Talks Hosting Oscars: ‘No Way’
More Videos
Halle Berry: Did Seth MacFarlane’s ‘Boob Song’ Strike A Sour Note With Her?
Halle Berry was surprised when she got a shout out in Seth MacFarlane’s controversial “boob song.” So, did the humor strike a sour note with her? Plus, what does Halle think about the toddler recreation of her metallic Versace gown from the Oscar red carpet?
Steve Carell: Being A Oscar Host Is A ‘Very Difficult Job’
While promoting his new comedy, “The Incredible Burt Wonderstone,” Steve Carell talks about how well Seth MacFarlane did as Oscar host and why it’s the toughest gig ever.
Oscars 2013: Get The Glamorous Red Carpet Style For Affordable Prices!
The Oscars red carpet was filled with beautiful ladies wearing gorgeous — but pricey — gowns. Style expert Rachel Zalis hosts a fashion show featuring the same looks for a fraction of the cost through Rent The Runway. To find out how you can get these looks for less, go to www.RentTheRunway.com.
Jennifer Lawrence Reacts To Her Miss Dior Handbag Campaign Photos
Jennifer Lawrence chats with Access’ Billy Bush on the Oscars 2013 red carpet where he showed the young star her Miss Dior handbag campaign photos for the first time. So, what did she think of the photos?
Oscars 2013: Get Anne Hathaway’s Glamorous Red Carpet Hair & Makeup!
Frederic Fekkai’s celebrity stylist Adir Abergel and Chanel celebrity makeup artist Kate Lee are the masterminds behind Anne Hathaway’s gorgeous hair and makeup at the Oscars. Now, they visit Access Hollywood Live to show how they whipped up such a standout look.
Which Star Came Closest To Correctly Guessing The Oscar Running Time?
With all the musical numbers at the Oscars, it appeared we might be in for a long night. With that in mind, Access’ Billy Bush thought he’d offer up a prize on the red carpet to the star that got the closest to predicting the show’s running time. So, which star won?
Vanity Fair Oscar Party: Daniel Day-Lewis On His Oscar Win - ‘It Always Comes As A Surprise’
Daniel Day-Lewis chats with Access at the 2013 Vanity Fair Oscar party about his Best Actor win at the Oscars. Even though everyone expected him to win, why does it still come as a surprise to him? Plus, has he ever taken a moment to reflect on just how good he really is?
Vanity Fair Oscar Party: Christoph Waltz On His Oscar Win - What Makes It Special?
Christoph Waltz chats with Access at the 2013 Vanity Fair Oscar party about his Best Supporting Actor win at the Oscars. What make winning the Oscar special for him? Plus, why doesn’t he like to read press about himself?
Vanity Fair Oscar Party: Catherine Zeta-Jones On Her Chicago Reunion - ‘It Was Really Nostalgic’
Catherine Zeta-Jones chats with Access at the 2013 Vanity Fair Oscar party about reuniting with her former cast of “Chicago” for a performance at this year’s Oscars. What was it like being back together again?
Vanity Fair Oscar Party: Bryan Cranston Talks Argo Winning Best Picture
Bryan Cranston chats with Access at the 2013 Vanity Fair Oscar party about “Agro” taking home the Best Picture Oscar. Did he know this movie was going to be a contender when they made it?
Vanity Fair Oscar Party: Chris Tucker Reacts To Co-Star Jennifer Lawrence’s Oscar Fall
Chris Tucker chats with Access at the 2013 Vanity Fair Oscar party about being a part of the awards season. Why does he say it’s just as much fun to be nominated as it is to win? Plus, what did he think about his “Silver Linings Playbook” co-star Jennifer Lawrence tripping on her way to accept her Oscar?
Vanity Fair Oscar Party: Russell Brand On Seth MacFarlane As Oscar Host - ‘He Did A Wonderful Job!’
Russell Brand chats with Access at the 2013 Vanity Fair Oscar party about Seth MacFarlane as Oscar host. What did he think about his taste in humor? Plus, why does Russell say it was a “glorious night for England” at the Oscars?
Vanity Fair Oscar Party: John Travolta & Kelly Preston Share Their Favorite 2013 Oscar Moments
John Travolta and Kelly Preston chat with Access at the 2013 Vanity Fair Oscar party about the favorite moments from the night. What did they think about the performances? And, what did they think about Seth MacFarlane as host?
Vanity Fair Oscar Party: Anne Hathaway Reacts To Her Oscar Win
Anne Hathaway chats with at the 2013 Vanity Fair Oscar party about starting out the night as the favored to win the Oscar. Did that add additional pressure? Would she have been disappointed had she not won?
Vanity Fair Oscar Party: Richard Gere - Reuniting With The Cast Of Chicago Was ‘So Much Fun’
Richard Gere chats with Access at the 2013 Vanity Fair Oscar party about reuniting with his former cast of “Chicago.” What memories did it bring back? Plus, what did he think of Seth MacFarlane hosting abilities? Did he do a good job?
Oscars 2013: Seth MacFarlane’s Dad & Sister Rachael - What Kind Of Kid Was Seth?
Seth MacFarlane’s father Ronald and his sister Rachael chat with Access’ Billy Bush on the red carpet at the 2013 Oscars. What kind of kid was Seth growing up? Was he a pain or the ideal kid? Plus, why does Rachael say hosting the Oscars is in Seth’s blood?
Vanity Fair Oscar Party: Gerard Butler Talks Living It Up After The Oscars
Gerard Butler chats with Access at the 2013 Vanity Fair Oscar party about hitting the Oscar after parties. What does he enjoy more, the parties or the limo ride between parties? Plus, what did someone spot happening in a hotel window? Also, what did Gerard think of Seth MacFarlane as Oscar host?
Vanity Fair Oscar Party: Andy Samberg Weighs In On Seth MacFarlane As Oscar Host
Andy Samberg chats with Access at the 2013 Vanity Fair Oscar party about Seth MacFarlane as host of the Oscars. What did he think of Seth’s jokes? Which of the jokes was his favorite? Plus, as a comedian himself, does he have a hard time just enjoying a joke or does he feel the need to dissect it?
Vanity Fair Oscar Party: Jennifer Hudson Talks Performing At The Oscars - Does She Still Get Nervous?
Jennifer Hudson chats with Access at the 2013 Vanity Fair Oscar party about performing at the Oscars. Does she still get nervous before a performance? And, does performing in front of the Oscar crowd make it worse? Plus, what did she think about Jennifer Lawrence falling?
Vanity Fair Oscar Party: Hugh Jackman Talks Performing With His Les Miserables Cast At The Oscars
Hugh Jackman chats with Access at the 2013 Vanity Fair Oscar party about getting to perform with his “Les Miserables” cast at the Oscars. Why will it be something he’ll never forget? Plus, did he get a little choked-up when Anne Hathaway won for Best Supporting Actress?
Vanity Fair Oscar Party: David O. Russell - ‘I’m Very Happy’ For Jennifer Lawrence
“Silver Linings Playbook” director David O. Russell chats with Access at the 2013 Vanity Fair Oscar party about Jennifer Lawrence taking home the Best Actress Oscar. Plus, why does David say it’s important to “stay humble,” regardless of whether you win or not?
Oscars 2013: Louise Roe’s Red Carpet Fashion Hits & Misses, Part II
“Fashion Star” host Louise Roe shares her favorite looks from the Oscars red carpet. Which actress’ dress was the perfect fit for her skin tone? Plus, which star had the worst look of the night? “Fashion Star” Season 2 premieres March 8 at 8/7c on NBC.
Oscars 2013: Louise Roe’s Red Carpet Fashion Hits & Misses, Part I
“Fashion Star” host Louise Roe shares her picks for the best and worst looks at the 2013 Academy Awards. Which actress’ dress does Louise call unflattering? Also, what were some of the most prominent style trends of the night? “Fashion Star” Season 2 premieres March 8 at 8/7c on NBC.
Oscars Governor’s Ball 2013: Ang Lee Wins Best Director
“Life of Pi” director Ang Lee chats with Access’ Shaun Robinson about what went through his mind when he was announced as the winner for Best Director. Also, he talks about getting emotional during his acceptance speech.
Oscars Governor’s Ball 2013: George Clooney’s ‘Fun Night’
After winning the Oscar for Best Picture, “Argo” producer George Clooney talks with Access’ Shaun Robinson about the fun time he had at the 85th Academy Awards. Also, he jokes that Ben Affleck’s acceptance speech was “all fake.”
More Galleries
Oscars 2013: The Parties
All the stars at the Oscars parties!
Oscars 2013: The Winners
Who took home the coveted statues at the 2013 Oscars?
Oscars 2013: Inside The Show
All the action from cinema’s biggest night!
Oscars 2013: Red Carpet Stars
Hot shots of all the stars on the Oscars red carpet!
Most Memorable Oscar Style Stars
Oscars Flashback: Red Carpet Stars 2012
A look back at all of the style as the stars hit the 2012 Oscars.
The Unbelievably Stylish Sarah Jessica Parker
Hot shots of Sarah Jessica Parker!
Johnny Depp: Hollywood’s Man Of Many Faces
Johnny Depp: Hollywood’s Man Of Many Faces
Oscars 2012: The Winners
Who took home the coveted statues at the 2012 Oscars?
Oscars 2012: 10 Best Dressed Red Carpet Stars
10 of Hollywood’s elite rock the red carpet of the 84th Academy Awards
Oscar 2012: Bow-Tied Gents
The gentlemen on the Red Carpet bring on classy bow-ties this season.
Oscars 2012: Inside The Show
Oscars 2012: The Parties
Hot shots of all the stars at the many Oscar parties.
Oscars 2012: An All-White Affair
A collection of dazzling white dresses worn by Hollywood’s elite
Oscars Freshman Class 2012: Who Are The First-Time Nominees?
Meet this year’s first-time Oscar nominees!
Oscars’ Red Carpet Dreams: Brad Pitt & George Clooney At The Academy Awards
Hot shots of Brad Pitt and George Clooney at the Oscars over the years.
Inside The 2012 Oscar Luncheon
The Oscar nominees gather for the annual meet and greet in Beverly Hills!
2012 Oscars: And The Nominees Are…
The nominees for the 2012 Oscars.
Scenes From ‘Jimmy Kimmel’s Live After The Academy Awards’
Scenes from Jimmy Kimmel’s post Oscar show and faux infomercial!
Oscars 2011: Red Carpet Couples
Check out the hot couples to walk the Oscars 2011 red carpet!
Oscars 2011: Inside The Show
Check out all the moments from inside the Kodak Theatre!
Oscars 2011: The Winners
Who walked away a winner at the Academy Awards?
Oscars 2011: Sizzling Red Gowns
The ladies in red — stars hit the Oscars in sizzling red gowns!
Oscar 2011: Red Carpet Stars
See all the hottest stars from the 2011 Academy Awards!
Oscars 2011: Star Studded After Parties


